Sales you wouldn’t have made without the ads: new customers, and existing customers who come back because of an ad. Here’s how we find them, and how we cut the ads that only take credit.
When you pay for ads, the number that matters isn’t how many sales the ads touched. It’s how many sales happened because of the ads. Marketers call that incrementality: revenue you have that you wouldn’t have had without the ad.
It sounds obvious. It’s also where a lot of ad money quietly disappears.
Our goal is new revenue and profit for you: new customers, and existing customers who buy again because of an ad. What we don’t want is to sit in the middle and take a cut of a sale you would have made anyway.
We won’t pretend every sale is new, though. We run retargeting, and some people who see a retargeting ad were going to buy no matter what. No honest agency can tell you all of its sales are incremental. Our job is to keep that share small, find the ads that are only taking credit, and turn them off.
Would have bought anyway. Ads that only take credit for these get cut.
Bought because of the ads. New customers, and ones who came back. That’s the job.
How some agencies take credit for sales you’d have made anyway.
Nothing in the ad dashboard flags this. Every one of those sales really did happen after someone saw an ad. The question the dashboard can’t answer is whether the ad made any difference.
1Subscription retargeting
What some agencies do
Aim most of the ads at people who already subscribe. The report shows lots of sales every month, because those people buy every month. But they’d have bought anyway, and no new customers came in.
What we do
Keep retargeting to a small share of the budget, measure it with holdout tests, and judge it by new customers and extra purchases, not by how many sales it touched.
Example: who a subscription brand’s ads reached
95% already subscribe
Already subscribers: they buy every month anyway
New people: the only sales the ads could add
An example, not a real brand’s numbers.
2Branded search
What some agencies do
Put a lot of money into Google ads on your own business name. The conversion rate looks amazing, as high as 40 to 50% in accounts we’ve seen, because those people were already searching for you.
What we do
Test turning it down. Keep it only where a competitor or a “best of” list is taking those clicks, and move the rest to what brings in new sales.
Free ad audit.
Send us a look at your current ads. We check how much of your money goes to retargeting (Facebook and Instagram ads to people who already visited your site) and how much to branded search (Google ads on your own name). Then we recommend a test you can run yourself, without us, to see whether you can lower your cost by cutting or reducing them.
Tests you could run yourself, for example:
Pause your own-name ads for two weeks and compare your revenue.
Cut retargeting to a small share of your budget and compare your new customers.
It’s free
We only look: read-only access, or screenshots
You don’t have to work with us to use the results
Thanks, . We have it.
We’ll be in touch about sharing your ads, then send you what we see and a test you can run yourself.
Many agencies put a lot of your money into Google ads on your own business name. It looks amazing, with conversion rates as high as 40 to 50% in accounts we’ve seen, because those people were already searching for you.
Sometimes you do need it. A competitor bids on your name and shows up above you, or an affiliate site’s “best of” list ranks for your name and takes the click. You don’t know until you test.
Turn your own-name ads down or off for a while
Revenue holds
You’d have shown up at the top anyway. Move that money to other searches, Facebook and Instagram, other channels or organic work.
Revenue drops
A competitor or a list is taking those clicks. Keep bidding, with a budget that matches what it actually protects.
How we test branded search.
The rule behind it: we keep testing whether we can remove spend and put the budget where it brings new sales. Not every dollar should be spent just because it can be.
When existing customers do count.
Existing customers aren’t the problem. A customer you’d lost, coming back because of an ad, is a real sale you wouldn’t have had.
Say you sell a daily health drink. Someone used it for a while, then stopped. A new ad comes up where an athlete they follow says they noticed the difference after three weeks, and they decide to start again. That person was already your customer, and the sale is still new. That’s exactly the kind of sale we want ads to bring in.
BeforeBought every month
ThenStopped buying
An adA new reason to try again
NowBack, and buying
An example. The sale after the ad is new: it wouldn’t have happened without it.
How we measure it.
You can’t see incrementality in one report. You have to test for it. These are the tests we use.
1
Holdout tests
We pause the ads for a set time and see what your sales do on their own. That’s your baseline, and anything above it while the ads run is what the ads are adding.
2
Geographic holdouts
Ads stay on in some areas and off in others that look alike. If sales rise only where the ads run, the ads are working.
3
Facebook and Instagram lift tests
Meta can split people into a group that sees your ads and a group that doesn’t, and compare what each group buys.
4
Google branded-search tests
People searching your business by name were already looking for you. We turn branded-search spend down and watch revenue. If it doesn’t drop, that money was taking credit for sales you’d have made anyway.
When a test shows an ad is only taking credit, we cut it and move the money to the ads that bring in new customers. We’d rather show you a smaller number that’s real than a big one that isn’t.
One honest caveat.
As spend goes up, ads reach people who are less interested, so the cost of each sale can rise. That doesn’t mean the ads stopped working. It means you’re reaching further. So we compare like with like, the same season, the same offer, a similar budget, before we call a change good or bad.
What this means for you.
You keep your own ad accounts, so you can see every number we see. We agree on a goal before we spend a dollar, we test whether the ads are adding sales, and we tell you when they aren’t. That’s how a percentage of ad spend stays fair: we only want to earn more when the ads are making you money you wouldn’t have had.